Translated automatically from the French version of Kelclinic. Contact us for remarks, questions or help.
russian English French German italian spanish
The reasons for the collapse of the Boeing flight 777 MH17 in Ukraine
The reasons for the collapse of the Boeing flight 777 MH17 in Ukraine

The reasons for the collapse of the Boeing flight 777 MH17 in Ukraine



Demonstrated the first evidence of a plane crash occurredBoeing 777on the territory of Ukraine.

Photograph made by American, British or probably a satellite, clearly demonstrates that the airliner might have been hit by a missile of class "air-to-air." It should be noted that in the course of the examination, no traces of photomontage in the picture has not been revealed, and even more than that, this information has been confirmed by an expert from the 20-years of experience George Bilt, according to which the aircraft was first fired air gun and then struck by two missiles of class "air-to-air."

According to the first assumption, the picture depicts a fighterMiG-27But previously the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation claimed that in the vicinity of the Malaysian airliner was zasechёn attack aircraft Su-25.

It is expected that the current information will soon be available to international experts, which will establish whether a satellite image original, or is it a photomontage.

Photo Boeing crash Donetsk



Available versions crashMH17


The mysterious collapse of the Malaysian aircraft under Ukrainian Torez creates a more and more disputes, all of whom are versatile, and is not completed a formal investigation of the plane crash, say anything about in whose hands is the blood of 298 people it is too early.

However, if the detail consider all possible versions of what happened with the crash of flight MH17, we can distinguish 6 basic versions of what happened, and if you do not go into deep detail, all of them can be explained as the existing currents of, and scientifically.

The first version is by far the most intensive consideration and it is in the fact that the plane was hit by anti-aircraft missile systems "Buk". Despite the fact that this is one of the basic versions of what happened, it is necessary to consider all possible variants of this.


Boeing 777 airline "malaysia Airlines »was shot down by the Russian military


This version of events appeared almost immediately after the plane was shot down, moreover, it appeared from the Ukrainian authorities. However, jumping to conclusions quickly did not materialize because the fallen plane from the border with the Russian Federation in 60 kilometers, which, as we know, the tactical and technical characteristics of SAM "Buk" indicate that defeat the purpose can be accomplished no further 35 kilometers, while it is carried out in the capture radius 150 kilometers.



At the same time, there is a version that the plane could have been shot down by other means of defense, such as missile systems S-300, the range of which is much wider, however, because the missiles of this class left a noticeable infrared stream and not to notice them by satellite It is simply impossible that the Ministry of Defense of the United States and confirmed that this version is not supported.

It should also pay attention to the fact that Russia has absolutely no motive to shoot down the Malaysian airliner since the two countries established friendly relations, and in recent years the EU and the US has been applied to Russia different kinds of sanctions, and exacerbation of this is clearly not the most the best way would affect the country's image.


Boeing 777 airline "malaysia Airlines »LC was hit by militias and DNI


This version today is shared by most of the EU countries themselves and the authorities of Ukraine. Himself reason for this is that the passenger flight MH17 fell on the territory of the self-proclaimed People's Republic of Donetsk. This version is almost similar to the previous - Malaysia Boeing 777 plane was shot down by SAM "Buk".



It would seem that everything points to the fact that Boeing 777 flight MH17 owned airline «Malaysia Airlines» was shot down from this area, however, said some time ago he official Kiev, before the moment when the SAM "Buk" were captured, they They were disabled soldiers of the National Guard of Ukraine, to provide the most complete loss of use of these weapons by the adversary. In itself, the equipment SAM "Buk" is very difficult to restore it, and in the field are absolutely not given possible.

However, if we take into account the fact that militias DNI and LC still had a battle-worthy setting for its use necessary qualified personnel, since the system only works in analog mode, and requires a minimum of 1 years of preparation.

In view of all these factors, it can be argued that any action by the militias and LC DNI eliminated, or at least very unlikely.

Boeing 777 airline "malaysia Airlines »was hit by a Ukrainian military


This version came from the Russian authorities, and, it would seem, at first glance, it is very unlikely, but in reality, there are a lot of very interesting fact. Version of itself, as in the previous case, is that the aircraft could again be destroyed by anti-aircraft missile systems "Buk".



It should be noted that in Ukraine there are dozens of SAM "Buk", and given the fact that the current conflict between Russia and Ukraine has grown on a large scale, the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine could well put these anti-aircraft systems near its borders, so that in case attacks reflect the possible air attacks. Qualified personnel in the ranks of the Ukrainian National Guard plenty, so pick the right people is not so difficult.

Just a few hours after the incident plane crash a version that the downed plane Boeing 777 flight MH17 was adopted as a Russian presidential aircraft, and if you carefully consider this version, both of these aircraft are almost identical, and to distinguish them from the radar anti-missile system is impossible. Currently in Ukraine there are often anti-Russian slogans and statements, and therefore it may be a good motive for the destruction of the aircraft.

Finally, another fact that Boeing belonging 777 «Malaysia Airlines» was hit by a Ukrainian military is simple physics, the crash occurred. As you know, the plane crashed near the town of Torez, but given the fact that the plane is still almost completely fell to the ground, it can be assumed that the trajectory of his fall was parabolic, that is, until it hit the ground, the aircraft flew a distance by their inertia, and if we make the calculations, we can see that the aircraft flew more about 120-150 kilometers, and from this we can conclude that the missile launch took place from the territory of the Dnipropetrovsk region.



However, given the large mass of the rocket and its speed of about 2.5 thousand kilometers per hour, it can be argued that if the plane was shot down this SAM, the plane would have fallen in place of the crash, with the probability that he has stayed to whole pieces very unlikely.

Boeing 777 airline "malaysia Airlines »has fallen due to a technical problem


According to experts, the likelihood that the crash affected by a technical failure, less than one-hundredth of a percent. This can ensure a rather simple example. As is well known by the instructions, if the pilot on board the aircraft detects any technical fault, he must immediately notify the nearest air traffic controller and had only then take any steps to eliminate it. Besides, as you know, part of the plane scattered in the air and there is already a serious problem with the rest.

Flight MH17 airline "malaysia Airlines »could be destroyed by an act of terrorism


By unknown reasons, this version is considered almost Commission conducting an analysis of the crash occurred, but is under a lot of curious facts.



As you know, not so long ago, the US government called on EU countries to tighten control at airports in connection with possible terrorist attacks, but not all countries have taken into account that, including the Netherlands. In addition, it is possible that an explosive device on board the aircraft could be operated remotely and installed on board the aircraft in advance.

Today world organizations say that the terrorist attacks on planes carried out, usually at lower elevations, but it's just statistics, and it is possible that on board the aircraft Boeing 777 flight MH17 explosive device was powered by a large adjustment.

The motive of this fact is unfortunately not yet been found, but it is possible that the experts will consider this option.

Malaysian plane was destroyed Ukrainian fighters


There are several circumstances, consideration of a release, and they are usually in evidence emerged after the disaster. Spanish air traffic controller, who worked on that fateful day control tower in Kiev, said in his microblog that Malaysian Boeing 777 MH17 2 flight accompanied by fighters, and after a moment, the fighters took the opposite course, and even a few minutes airliner with 298 people on its board disappeared from radar.



It is worth noting that this version of the incident as very likely, because given the fact that most of the fighters are using homing missiles, which are not able to fully stitch the plane, but may destroy it, and if you believe the personnel from the scene, we can see that the plane was only partially destroyed, and part of it flew to the ground, where later he was found. Based on these facts, we can confirm that this version is quite possible, however, to prove it can be used only if the search for the wreckage of an airliner on the spot where the plane was shot down, as some of them had to drop almost vertically - to be more precise the in 100 kilometers from the crash site.

However, all the mentioned versions are not officially proven, and only a formal investigation may either confirm them or deny, and yet the reason why the plane was shot down over the Malaysian territory of Ukraine, it remains a mystery.


This question is to determine whether you are a human automated spam submissions.

"According to the first assumption, the picture depicts a MiG-27, however, previously the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation claimed that in the vicinity of the Malaysian airliner was zasechёn attack aircraft Su-25."

__ Guys, well, if you write a serious article, then let's be accurate in everything.
__ I quote from the RF Ministry of Defense briefing:
"In addition, the Russian air control means conditions fixed climbing aircraft Ukrainian Air Force _predpolozhitelno_Su-25-go_ in the direction of the Malaysian Boeing."
In addition, it is possible that there were two planes, what was also information ...